How to choose between the Arctic and Antarctic for your Polar Voyage

September 28, 2020

By Nick Engelmann

The Arctic or Antarctica? Oh, life´s choices. 

So, you´ve decided to trade in your sandals and swimsuit for wool socks and a parka.

You’re not sure where the idea originated. Perhaps a documentary narrated by the British master of nature documentaries, David Attenborough, or perhaps the notion was prompted by a stunning photograph that popped up on Instagram. Then again, maybe it was a travel tale recounted by an adventurous friend who suggested you—yes you—could travel to the polar regions. The cold climates were unexpectedly calling you and now all that’s left for you is to choose: Arctic or the Antarctic?

If you're keen to see penguins, you'll want to book yourself onto an Antarctic voyage.
There are no penguins in the Arctic. Photo: David Merron 

It's a simple strategy: for penguins you go to the Antarctic. For majestic polar bears,
you'll want to join an Arctic expedition. Photo: David Merron 

North or South? Down or Up? Where should I go?

Whichever Polar Region you choose, rest assured it will be fantastic and life changing. If you follow in the footsteps of great polar explorers like Roald Amundsen and James Clark Ross, it’s possible you’ll want to journey to both Polar Regions. (But which would you choose for your first voyage?)  In tandem with this blog, I invite you to check out my full webinar "Arctic vs.  Antarctic: Identifying the Differences."


Choosing your Polar Region

The Arctic is an ocean surrounded by continents while Antarctica is a continent surrounded by ocean. We visit the Arctic in the northern hemisphere summer (June to October) and the Antarctic in the southern hemisphere summer (October to March). Trips vary anywhere from just over a week to nearly a month, so timing alone might determine your choice. And then within in each region there are sub regions and voyages that travel to those specific areas. 

We can certainly help you decide by pointing out what each region has to offer.

The Arctic

Season: June to October.

What do you wish to see:

Wildlife: The Arctic has greater terrestrial and marine diversity than the Antarctic, however Arctic wildlife tends to be more elusive, partly because of polar bears and the long history of hunting.

Polar bears: While sightings aren´t guaranteed, your best chances to see these majestic animals are Svalbard, the Russian Arctic and the Canadian Arctic, in that order.

Whales: Guests will see whales in most regions though whale sightings are less predictable than in the Antarctic. Species visitors are likely to see include humpback whales, fin whales, minke whales, blue whales (though sightings are rare), killer whales (also called orca, but sighted infrequently), beluga whales (rare), bowhead whales (in the Canadian Arctic) and narwhal (very rare), 

 

There are historical sites, former whaling stations and other landmarks throughout the Arctic. Photo: Grange Productions 


Walruses: Svalbard, Russian Arctic and Canadian Arctic (in that order) 

Inuit (Indigenous) communities: Visits to local communities are possible in Greenland and Arctic Canada.

 

The Arctic landscape can be surprisingly colorful, especially the tundra. Photo: Visit Greenland 

Tundra:  North of the treeline, where permafrost prevents trees from growing, is a vast ecosystem, bleak but beautiful, and while seemingly inhospitable and empty the tundra can reveal a surprising bounty of life.

North Pole:  Travelers can visit 90º North—the very top of the world—on select voyages by icebreaker.

Crossing the Arctic Circle: An invisible line at 66º33´ North. Areas north of this line have at least one summer day on which the sun doesn´t set and one winter night when the sun never rises.

Glaciers and Icebergs: Glaciers are rivers of ice flowing out from even larger ice caps and ice sheets. Where glaciers reach the sea they break off, forming icebergs—spectacular sculptures of ice. 

Tundra flora:  A collage of hardy miniature flowers, shrubs and other plants with wonderful powers of adaptation that bring surprising bursts of life and colour to the harshest of our planet´s ecosystems.

Arctic Exploration History: Polar history enthusiasts have the opportunities to visit landmarks connected to early polar explorers such as Sir John Franklin and others. Watch our webinar, “The Fate of Sir John Franklin” 

Season: June to October.

Regions within the Arctic:

  • Russian High Arctic
  • Svalbard, the Norwegian archipelago, and high Arctic Islands
  • Greenland: East, South and West
  • Canadian High Arctic

 

Highlights of the Antarctic

Multiple species of penguins populate the Antarctic. Photo: David Merron 

Diverse Wildlife
Expect high densities of seals and penguins that aren’t elusive like wildlife species in the ArcticThere are wildlife-rich destinations within Antarctica such as South Georgia, which is known as the Galapagos of the Poles.

Penguins, penguins and more penguins:  Depending  whether you visit the Antarctica or subantarctic or even Snow Hill Island in the Weddell Sea, it’s possible to see a variety of penguins including the gentoo, chinstrap, Adelie, rockhopper, macaroni, magellanic, king, and if you´re really fortunate, the Emperor penguins of Snow Hill Island.

If you’d like to know more about the diverse species of penguins, check out our Polar Learning Channel webinar, "Penguins 101." 

Whales: whale season in the Antarctic extends from December to March. With the summer comes the great migratory species, including humpback, minke and fin whales, and you may even see killer whales (often referred to as Orca) hunting in the icy waters.

Whale-watching is popular in both the Arctic and Antarctic. Species vary according to region. Photo: David Merron 

 

Zodiacs tours are integral activities on voyages in both the Arctic and Antarctic. They're an excellent opportunity to
view wildlife at a safe distance. Photo: David Merron 


Seals: with no fear of humans, Antarctic seals are wonderful and unique, ranging from the impossibly enormous southern elephant seals on South Georgia to curious and reptilian-like leopard seals in icy Antarctic waters.

Birder´s paradise: Aside from penguins, the Antarctic and sub-Antarctic host a wonderful of variety of marine bird species such as the wandering albatross. You´ll find unique terrestrial species, (such as the flightless steamer duck), mostly in the Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas) and Chilean Fjord. For an example of the rich bird species, check out Acacia Johnson's blog "The Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas): A Birder's Paradise."

Icebergs take many different shapes in the polar regions. Photo: David Merron 

The magnitude of ice in both polar regions can leave visitors awestruck Photo: Grange Productions

Glacier and Iceberg galore: Icebergs come in all shapes and sizes from angular and chiseled sculptures, to dimpled and dome-shaped, to cathedral-like structures with spires and finally to spectacular tabular bergs sometimes the size of cities and states. Their unearthly white and blue tones seem to glow in the Antarctic air.

Antarctic Circle: located at 66° 33′ 39″ latitude south of the equator. There are 24 hours of twenty-four hours of daylight on the Summer Solstice in December.

Crossing the Drake Passage : the iconic 800-mile wide passage between  Cape Horn in South America and the South Shetland Islands in Antarctica is alternately called “Drake Shake” because of the rough waters or, when it’s calmer, “Drake Lake.” It's considered a rite of passage for many visitors to the Antarctic.

Antarctic Exploration History: Our South Georgia itineraries allow you to pay your respects to Sir Ernest Shackleton, one of the most storied Antarctic explorers in the history of polar exploration. Shackleton is buried at the historic whaling station of Grytviken, South Georgia.

Season: October to March

Regions within the Antarctic:

  • Antarctic Peninsula: first-time visitors are usually overwhelmed by the staggering beauty of the Antarctic Peninsula: glaciers, snow-covered mountain tops, deep blue waters and icebergs of every conceivable shape and size.
  • South Georgia: known as the Galapagos of the Poles because of its rich wildlife and biodiversity.
  • Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas): The sub-Antarctic archipelago of the Falkland Islands, or Islas Malvinas, is known for its wildlife—penguins and bird species are plentiful—as well as its dramatic history. 
  • Antarctic Circle crossing (on select voyages): located at 66° 33′ 39″ latitude south of the Equator. There are 24 hours of twenty-four hours of daylight on the Summer Solstice in December.
  • Snow Hill Island: on the rarely visited eastern side of the Antarctic Peninsula, Snow Hill Island is tucked into the Northwest Weddell Sea, where life seems impossible considering the frigid temperatures and carpet of sea ice. It’s home to the Antarctic´s most northern Emperor penguin colony, where an estimated 4,000 breeding pairs raise their chicks in this seemingly inhospitable home.

At the end of the day, choosing between the Arctic and Antarctic is a lot easier once you decide:

• What time of year you prefer to travel?

•  What kind of wildlife do you want to see in their natural setting?

•  What kind of landscape do you imagine yourself exploring?

For a more in-depth discussion of the Arctic vs. Antarctic highlights, watch Quark Expeditions’ Polar Learning Channel webinar "Arctic vs. Antarctic: Identifying the Differences." 

Previous Article
Why you should visit the Arctic in May
Why you should visit the Arctic in May

The warmer temperatures in May mean there are lots of Arctic wildlife to be seen in the Arctic.

Next Article
Escape the Crowds in the Arctic: Remote Spitsbergen
Escape the Crowds in the Arctic: Remote Spitsbergen

An Arctic voyage is the ideal way to escape the crowds. Arctic destinations such as Spitsbergen offer a bre...